When Silencing Becomes the Loudest Voice
If Freedom of Speech Falls, So Does the Republic
What Is Cancel Culture?
We’ve all been in this situation: someone confidently expresses an idea we find ridiculous or offensive, maybe even a conspiracy theory. The frustration can be so intense that we wish we could silence them entirely. It’s human nature to want to suppress ideas we find dangerous or “obviously wrong.”
But what if, at the risk of being “canceled” myself, I suggest that allowing those very ideas to be heard, however outlandish, is essential to an open society? A marketplace of ideas, where even conspiracies are debated rather than censored, creates accountability and encourages truth to emerge through scrutiny, not suppression.
Freedom of speech, including speech we despise, is worth defending, not only against government censorship but against social silencing by our fellow citizens. Was Noah not dismissed as a conspiracy theorist until the flood came? Was the horror of Nazi Germany not unthinkable until the liberation of the concentration camps revealed the truth? History teaches us that uncomfortable ideas must be heard before they can be proven, challenged, or corrected.
A culture that listens, then chooses whether to agree or disagree, strengthens itself. A culture that censors opposing views begins to decay from within.
John Adams and the Threat to Free Speech
The Founding Fathers created a Bill of Rights to protect citizens from government overreach, rights that many nations only dreamed of achieving under monarchies and corruption. Yet even in our early years, freedom of speech faced serious threats.
According to the National Constitution Center, President John Adams signed the Sedition Act of 1798, which made it illegal to criticize the government or the president. Though justified as a matter of national security, it was, in reality, a weapon to silence political opponents. The act is now widely recognized as a clear violation of the First Amendment, a stark reminder that even our founders struggled to uphold the very freedoms they established.
Portrait of John Adams by John Trumbull, circa 1792 — National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution.
How Has the United States Upheld Free Speech?
The battle for free expression has defined American democracy from its birth. Each generation has faced efforts, legislative, social, and cultural, to curtail it. Yet the republic has endured.
The preservation of this right ultimately rests not in government institutions but in citizens themselves. When people tolerate censorship, even in small doses, they invite a slow erosion of liberty. Freedom of speech is not merely a privilege, it’s a responsibility. It ensures accountability in government, truth in journalism, and resilience in society.
To preserve it, we must be willing to defend even the speech we hate, for once that freedom is lost, none of us will have a voice left to defend at all.
Thanks for reading The Keystone Exchange! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.